Category: Μεταφράσεις νομικών κειμένων

In the software development sector one topic discussed a lot these days is what will companies do when all the senior engineers retire if juniors never get the chance to reach seniority because artificial intelligence is doing the foundational work?

In software engineering, typing lines of code is only the visible surface of the profession. Beneath the syntax lies systems architecture and threat modelling, alongside a deep understanding of how a minor change in one module cascades through an entire enterprise infrastructure. Engineers acquire that architectural judgement by spending their early years writing code from scratch and debugging failures line by line.

The legal profession is now confronting this exact same dilemma. In law, much like in software engineering, the text on the screen is only the final output of a much deeper analytical process. Law firms have traditionally relied on trainees and junior associates drafting agreements, reviewing documents, and researching statutory provisions from the ground up to build the legal reasoning required at partner level. Handing those foundational tasks over to generative AI raises an urgent question for the legal sector: if junior lawyers bypass the formative work of constructing legal arguments from scratch, how will they ever develop the senior judgement needed to spot when an algorithm gets the law wrong?

“Fast Metis”, “Slow Metis”, and the trap of Fluent Mediocrity

Across the legal and professional services world, leading scholars are sounding the alarm over how automation disrupts the formation of senior judgement. In an April 2026 study for the Harvard Law School Center on the Legal Profession, titled The Training Crisis, Anthea Roberts and David Wilkins distinguish between two forms of practical wisdom in legal work: “fast metis” and “slow metis”.

Fast metis is the ability to operate AI tools rapidly to generate plausible-looking text. Slow metis is the deep domain expertise acquired over years of wrestling with primary legal sources and resolving complex statutory or contractual ambiguities from first principles. Roberts and Wilkins demonstrate that when high AI speed is combined with shallow domain mastery, the result is what they term “Fluent Mediocrity”: output that reads smoothly to a non-specialist while missing the binding legal constraints that govern the matter. Because automation targets the very foundational tasks that historically trained junior practitioners, every firm that substitutes AI for rigorous foundational work is consuming the capability pipeline the profession needs to function.

Research from Harvard Business School reinforces this distinction. In The Expertise Upheaval (Sigelman, Fuller, Fenlon et al., July 2025), researchers analysed millions of job roles and divided the knowledge economy into “Mastery Roles” and “Growth Roles”. Mastery Roles rely on front-loaded technical rules that remain relatively static, allowing automation to compress onboarding time. Growth Roles, which include legal practice and specialist advisory work, depend on a learning curve that intensifies over time through exposure to nuanced, judgement-heavy problems.

In these Growth Roles, automating foundational drafting hollows out the middle of the career ladder. As Dr Christophe Kolb observed in Forbes (September 2026), the first draft of a legal memo or complex document historically performed two jobs at once: it shipped, and it taught. Removing the cognitive struggle of building a text from the ground up imposes a hidden “Apprenticeship Tax”. At Stanford Law School’s Rhode Center on the Legal Profession (Engstrom, Knowlton, and George, November 2026), legal scholars and law firm leaders have raised the same question: when an algorithm generates the first draft and marks up the contract, how does a practitioner ever develop the professional judgement required to supervise the machine?

Equally, clients who instruct legal translators for cross-border corporate deals, property acquisitions, or litigation involving Greece and Cyprus face the exact same structural reality. Putting English words on a page is only the final, visible fraction of what a specialist legal translator actually does. When law firms and corporate boards buy into the narrative that generative AI can handle the “heavy lifting” of translation while a human merely checks the output, they mistake the surface artefact for the underlying legal engineering. Worse still, they rely on a market model that is actively eroding the senior expertise required to keep their transactions safe.

Why “Getting Words on the Page” is the smallest part of legal translation

For a foreign board of directors reviewing a Greek commercial contract, or an English solicitor advising on a Cypriot probate or corporate dispute, the primary obstacle appears to be language: the document is in Greek, and it needs to be in English. Because large language models and neural machine translation engines produce grammatically polished English prose in seconds, it is tempting for them to assume that the machine has done 90 per cent of the job.

Some recent empirical research into how legal translators actually work proves the opposite. Putting words on the page is simply the recording mechanism for a series of diagnostic and comparative legal decisions that happen before a sentence is finalised:

  • Testing legal propositions rather than reading surface grammar: In a December 2025 keylogging experiment using Translog-II software (Sayar Öztürk and Kumcu, 2025), researchers measured the cognitive and temporal effort of experienced translators alongside novices and field specialists as they worked on machine-translated legal documents. The inexperienced participants moved through the machine output quickly with brief pauses, reassured by the smooth grammar on the screen. The experienced translators exerted significantly higher cognitive and temporal effort, recording longer pauses per word and executing deep structural revisions. Because they possessed senior comparative judgement, they were looking past the words on the page to test whether the underlying legal obligations held up across jurisdictions.

  • Coordinating legal context with procedural reality: An October 2026 empirical study by Hu examined what happens when law students and translation trainees are given unrestricted access to AI tools while revising machine-translated legal texts. Despite having AI assistants and authoritative dictionaries at their fingertips, the participants repeatedly failed to correct critical legal misalignments. Having access to a dictionary equivalent or an AI suggestion could not compensate for the inability to distinguish between a term that is valid legal English in the abstract and one that is legally operative in the specific procedural context of the instrument.

Automated systems treat every word and clause in a document as a uniform statistical calculation. A senior human specialist, by contrast, reads a forty-page Greek pleading or regulatory filing with an eye for where the commercial or litigation danger sits. When a single verb or statutory reference carries the entire financial exposure of a deal, a senior lawyer-linguist recognises the stakes immediately, cross-checking Greek civil law authorities and alerting instructing counsel to ambiguities in the Greek original before any commercial step is taken.

The monolingual buyer’s blind spot: Correspondence errors and “Adverse selection”

Why does this distinction between surface words and deep legal judgement create such acute exposure for buyers of legal translation? The answer lies in information asymmetry.

In a September 2025 AI safety report published by Tranquality /LTAC Global (Why Translation Errors Must Be Part of the AI Safety Discussion), Dr Alan Melby and Ryan Foley explain why AI translation failures belong in a different risk category from monolingual AI errors. When a solicitor in London uses generative AI to summarise an English judgment, the solicitor reads English and can verify the summary against the source text. When that same solicitor or a foreign investor receives an English translation of a Greek or Cypriot legal document, they are operating in an asymmetric bilingual scenario. Because they cannot read the Greek source text at a specialist legal level, they have no way of fact-checking whether the English text accurately reflects the Greek original.

Melby and Foley identify correspondence errors (where the translated text is completely fluent and plausible in English while materially misrepresenting the source text) as the primary vector of legal and financial harm in cross-border workflows. Compounded by “fluency bias” (the human cognitive tendency to equate smooth syntax with factual accuracy), correspondence errors remain invisible to the client until a counterparty challenges a clause in court or a regulator rejects a filing.

This information gap triggers what economists call adverse selection. When buyers cannot visually distinguish between a cheap, machine-assisted draft and a rigorously researched legal translation (because both look like neat pages of English words), price becomes the primary basis for comparison. Low-cost providers offering rapid machine output undercut and crowd out thorough legal translation, while the mass market drives down fees and replaces senior specialists with junior post-editors checking machine output at speed. Yet, as the keylogging and revision studies demonstrate, a reviewer who has not spent years translating complex legal instruments from the ground up cannot spot the correspondence errors hidden beneath the fluent surface.

Why seniority cannot be automated

When a law firm, corporate board, or private client instructs a legal translator for a matter involving Greece or Cyprus, the deliverables are English (or Greek) words on a page. What the client is actually purchasing, however, is the decades of “slow metis” that determine which words belong there and what legal consequences they trigger.

That senior judgement is built through formal legal education and academic research, combined with thousands of hours of primary legal translation and direct engagement with Greek and Cypriot statutes, case law, and notarial or corporate practice. As we explain in our guides on Why AI Legal Translation Is a False Economy and Why Clients Choose JurTrans, senior comparative judgement cannot be replicated by a predictive algorithm, and it cannot be safeguarded by a junior reviewer skimming a machine-generated draft.

In software engineering and in cross-border law alike, there is no shortcut to seniority. When the stakes involve enforceable obligations, property rights, regulatory compliance, or judicial proceedings, the only safeguard against fluent mediocrity is a practitioner who has done the hard yards to master both the law and the language from first principles.

At JurTrans, every Greek and Cypriot legal translation is handled directly at a senior level by a specialist who thinks and writes like a lawyer and understands the practical mechanics of how Greek, Cypriot, and English legal systems interact. Whether you are a foreign board overseeing a Greek subsidiary, a law firm coordinating cross-border litigation, or a private client navigating property or inheritance documentation in Greece or Cyprus, our work gives you clear, reliable visibility into your rights, obligations, and commercial exposure. If you need Greek or Cypriot legal documents translated with rigorous legal precision, get in touch with JurTrans to discuss how we can assist.

Ten Years from Google Translate to ChatGPT: Why Machine and AI Legal Translation Carries Severe Consequences for Clients and Lawyers

By John O’Shea (LL.B. (Hons), LL.M.)

1. A Decade of Technological Evolution, The Same Underlying Hazard

Across commercial law firms, corporate legal departments, and private litigation, a quiet assumption has taken hold that pasting foreign-language correspondence, witness statements, statutory provisions, or commercial agreements into a machine translation engine or generative AI chatbot carries no real consequence. Users frequently rationalise this practice by telling themselves that the output is merely for preliminary orientation, internal comprehension, or an informal check before instructing external counsel.

Empirical research into legal workflows confirms how deeply entrenched this attitude has become. In a survey of practising lawyers in Greece that I co-authored with Kyriaki Kourouni in Revista Tradumàtica (2025), practitioners reported turning to machine translation primarily to grasp the basic meaning of foreign texts (9.28%), manage cross-border client communications (8.25%), review internal documents (7.22%), and examine draft commercial contracts (6.19%). Strikingly, whilst 35.72% of the surveyed lawyers recognised that uploading legal material into free online translation tools breaches client confidentiality, 0% of respondents expressed any fear of being sued for professional malpractice or legal liability as a consequence of relying on machine output.

A decade of case law across common law and civil law jurisdictions demonstrates that this complacency is misplaced. Ten years ago, litigants who placed unverified Google Translate outputs before tribunals watched their evidence get rejected and their claims fail because statistical machine translation produced visibly broken syntax. Today, ten years down the line, the transition to neural machine translation (NMT) and large language models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT has failed to eliminate the underlying jurilinguistic hazard. By replacing obvious syntactic incoherence with polished, authoritative-sounding prose, modern artificial translation has made substantive errors far harder to detect, expanding the fallout to encompass both the client whose substantive rights are compromised and the legal practitioner whose professional conduct comes under judicial or disciplinary scrutiny.

2. Why Fluent AI Output Traps Both Clients and Counsel

To understand why modern AI translation creates acute legal exposure, one must look at how language models process legal text. In earlier generations of machine translation, defective output announced itself through garbled grammar that immediately warned a careful lawyer or company director to treat the text with caution. As Juliette Scott and I demonstrated in our Legal Translation Vulnerability Scoping framework (Research Handbook on Jurilinguistics, Edward Elgar, 2023), neural networks and generative AI replaced that visible awkwardness with an illusion of fluidity.

Machine learning systems optimise for probabilistic plausibility rather than comparative legal equivalence. When translating between legal orders that do not share the same conceptual architecture, such as the continental European civil law tradition of Greece and the common law systems of England and Wales or the United States, surface fluency masks severe doctrinal distortions. In our chapter Words Matter: How AI Pollutes the Language of the Law (International Handbook of Legal Language and Communication, Springer Nature, 2026), Argyri Panezi and I analysed how English-dominated training corpora introduce systematic jurisdiction bias and technology-mediated legal transplants into translated legal texts.

Empirical studies of Greek-to-English and English-to-Greek AI outputs illustrate how easily these systems flatten or displace statutory concepts:

  • Criminal and Regulatory Classification: In Greek criminal and regulatory compliance matters, automated systems routinely collapse the statutory tripartite division of offences under the Greek Penal Code (κακούργημα, πλημμέλημα, and πταίσμα) into generic English words such as “crime” or “offence”, or import Anglo-American common law concepts by rendering δόλος (dolus) as mere “intent” and αναστολή ποινής (suspension of sentence) as “probation”.

  • Civil and Corporate Acts: In civil and commercial contexts, neural translation systems have rendered a private-law legal transaction or juridical act (δικαιοπραξία) as “jurisdiction” (δικαιοδοσία), and reduced a formal criminal complaint subject to strict statutory time limits (έγκληση) to an informal “report”.

  • Appellate and Procedural Finality: As Daniel Webber and I documented when translating the Greek procedural codes (Translating Greece’s Procedural Codes, ELETO, 2023), even traditional legal dictionaries and automated tools routinely flatten the distinct procedural stages of Greek court decisions into the single English phrase “final judgment”. Under the Greek Code of Civil Procedure, however, an οριστική απόφαση disposes of the action before the first-instance court whilst remaining subject to ordinary appeal, a τελεσίδικη απόφαση denotes a judgment where ordinary appellate remedies have been exhausted or expired, an ανέκκλητη απόφαση refers to a decision that is by law not amenable to ordinary appeal, and an αμετάκλητη απόφαση signifies an irrevocable judgment no longer open to cassation before the Hellenic Supreme Court (Areios Pagos). A translation that renders all four categories simply as a “final judgment” misleads foreign counsel on the fundamental question of whether a judgment can still be challenged or enforced.

Furthermore, as Pierre Moor (2026) has observed in the context of legal interpretation, statutory and contractual provisions frequently contain deliberate normative ambiguity or open-textured concepts whose scope must be resolved by a court rather than a translator. When a generative AI model encounters an ambiguous source provision, it silently selects the most statistically probable English phrasing, committing the reader to a single substantive interpretation without alerting counsel that the original text admitted more than one reading.

Nor can this problem be solved simply by asking a reviewer to “post-edit” machine output. As Vilelmini Sosoni, Maria Stasimioti, and I demonstrated in our empirical comparison of from-scratch human translation and machine translation post-editing (Journal of Language and Law, 2022), the grammatical smoothness of neural output primes even trained reviewers to overlook major terminological and accuracy errors, creating a false sense of security whilst shifting full professional liability onto the human who signs off on the text.

3. Ten Years of Machine Translation in the Courts: From Early MT to Modern AI (2016–2026)

If technological progress had solved the risks of automated legal translation, judicial decisions criticizing defective machine translations would have faded into history after the mid-2010s. Instead, the case law from 2016 to 2026 shows a continuous line of evidentiary failures across tax tribunals, commercial courts, and statutory tribunals.

The 2016 Benchmark: Rejected Evidence and £243,564 in Tax Liability

Ten years ago, two decisions before the UK First-tier Tribunal (Tax Chamber) illustrated the immediate financial and procedural cost of relying on unverified translations in cross-border proceedings:

  • KIP UK Ltd v Revenue and Customs [2016] UKFTT 821 (TC): In a customs duty dispute, a party sought to rely on English translations generated through Google Translate. The Tribunal upheld the opposing party’s formal objection to the evidence, ruling that the machine translation “did not produce any meaningfully comprehensible summary” upon which a judicial body could rely.

  • Essential Telecom Ltd v Revenue and Customs [2016] UKFTT 475 (TC): In a cross-border value-added tax dispute involving £243,564, HM Revenue and Customs relied on unverified translations of Italian Guardia di Finanza investigation reports concerning an Italian counterparty. The UK Tribunal refused to admit the disputed evidence, characterising it as double hearsay and finding that the defective translations had caused “many wrong assumptions about the corporate or non-corporate form of the counterparty”.

Ten Years Later: NMT and ChatGPT in Commercial and Statutory Litigation

Move forward a decade to the era of neural machine translation and generative AI, and litigants are encountering the exact same judicial wall, now compounded by AI fabrication:

  • Euroboor BV v Grafova: In commercial litigation before a United States court, a party submitted a Google Translate version of a Dutch court judgment on which its legal argument relied. Despite a decade of neural network upgrades since 2016, the American court struggled to decipher the judicial reasoning in the machine-translated Dutch judgment, demonstrating that raw MT remains incapable of conveying complex foreign judicial reasoning to a common law bench.

  • Lozano González v Roberge: Before a Canadian tribunal, a litigant relied on a ChatGPT translation of foreign statutory provisions to support their legal case. Upon scrutiny, the tribunal found that ChatGPT had not merely translated the legislation inaccurately; the chatbot had effectively rewritten the statutory provisions on which the litigant’s argument depended.

This phenomenon of statutory distortion aligns directly with the empirical test reported in Panezi & O’Shea (2026), where ChatGPT, queried in English regarding a civil dispute under Greek law, fabricated confident English translations and doctrinal interpretations of Articles 1003 to 1010 of the Greek Civil Code. Across the globe, more than 2,000 judicial decisions have now documented the submission of AI-fabricated legal authorities and distorted statutory texts, a trend that has begun to trigger direct commercial litigation against AI vendors themselves, such as Nippon Life v OpenAI (filed in March 2026).

4. Consequences for the Client: Substantive Loss and ‘Terminology Drift’ in Commercial Disputes

For corporate and private clients, the danger of casual or uncoordinated translation extends well beyond a single rejected exhibit. Commercial relationships and cross-border investments evolve over many years. Agreements are negotiated and signed, board minutes and financial disclosures under Greek Law 4548/2018 are recorded, correspondence is exchanged when commercial friction arises, and extrajudicial notices are served when the relationship breaks down.

A recent decision of the Hellenic Supreme Court, Judgment No. 221/2026, provides a textbook demonstration of how translation choices made at different stages of a commercial venture can become a central forensic issue in high-value litigation.

The dispute arose out of a long-running wind-energy project in Greece between a Greek project developer and a Spanish corporate investor. Although the wind-energy project was situated in Greece, the commercial relationship between the parties was governed by contracts drafted in English. When the commercial relationship broke down, the Spanish investor served an extrajudicial notice declaring that it had decided to “terminate the … Contracts and withdraw from the Project”, proposing to transfer its shares in the project company for a nominal consideration pursuant to Article 5.2 of the Framework Agreement.

When the dispute reached the Greek courts, the legal characterisation and validity of that notice turned heavily on how the English contractual terms had been translated into Greek across the documentary record:

  1. Inconsistent Rendering of the Core Contractual Mechanism (“Withdrawal”): In translating the Framework Agreement, the Greek developer rendered the heading “Withdrawal” as Υπαναχώρηση (the Greek civil law concept of statutory or contractual rescission/withdrawal). The Spanish investor’s translation of the heading used the more general word Απόσυρση, yet within the operative clauses of the Spanish investor’s own translation, the phrase “withdraw from their obligations” was rendered using υπαναχώρηση, while a third variant, αποχώρηση (departure/exit), also appeared in the arguments. The Court of Appeal expressly noted this terminological inconsistency across the translations before concluding, from the contractual mechanism of the share transfer, that “withdrawal” operated in Greek law as contractual υπαναχώρηση.

  2. Disputed Translation of Commercial Thresholds (“Feasibility”): Under Article 3.5 of the Project Agreement, the investor’s right to withdraw was conditional upon the project’s “technical and financial feasibility” proving insufficient. One translation rendered “feasibility” as βιωσιμότητα (viability/sustainability), whereas the Court of Appeal held that σκοπιμότητα (expediency/feasibility in context) was the appropriate rendering within the architecture of the clause. Ultimately, the courts found that the investor’s notice failed to specify whether the alleged inadequacy was technical, financial, or both, and failed to identify the supporting data, resulting in the dismissal of the investor’s cassation appeal before the Supreme Court.

Hellenic Supreme Court Judgment No. 221/2026 illustrates what happens when translation is treated as an isolated lexical exercise rather than a file-level legal strategy. When a corporate client or legal team feeds a newly received extrajudicial notice, board resolution, or commercial letter into an AI tool or commissions an ad hoc translation without cross-referencing the terminology established years earlier in the underlying framework agreement, terminology drift enters the file. Because generative AI translates probabilistically, it will readily render an ordinary-looking English word like “withdrawal”, “feasibility”, “material”, or “default” using one Greek synonym in 2021 and a different Greek term in 2026. Once those documents are placed side by side before a court, the client has to pay counsel to litigate avoidable ambiguities created by their own translations.

5. Consequences for the Lawyer: Judicial Criticism, Disciplinary Exposure, and Malpractice

While clients bear the commercial and substantive fallout of defective translations, recent decisions from 2025 and 2026 demonstrate that practising lawyers face acute reputational, procedural, and disciplinary exposure when AI-translated material enters a legal file.

Judicial Rebuke for Overlooking AI Provenance: AA v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2026]

In AA v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2026] UKFTT PA747122024 (IAC), an appellant’s solicitors filed an English witness letter in support of an asylum appeal before the UK First-tier Tribunal (Immigration and Asylum Chamber). The English text read fluently and appeared to support the appellant’s factual account. However, at the end of the witness letter sat a conspicuous sentence offering to turn the letter into a formal affidavit, insert notarisation language, or make the wording more neutral.

First-tier Tribunal Judge CJ Williams immediately recognised the sentence for what it was: a conversational follow-up prompt generated by a chatbot. Upon questioning by the judge, the witness explained that he had written his account in Arabic, used ChatGPT to translate it into English, and then asked his daughter to compare the English output against the Arabic original to check that the meaning was the same.

At paragraph [28] of the judgment, Judge Williams delivered a pointed observation directed at the legal representatives who had placed the document into the court bundle:

“It is unfortunate that it fell to the Tribunal to notice this.”

For litigation solicitors and counsel, AA exposes two distinct professional vulnerabilities:

  • Failure of Basic Document Control: Detecting the leftover ChatGPT prompt at the foot of the witness statement required no knowledge of Arabic. It required only that the legal team read the English exhibit carefully from start to finish before filing it with the Tribunal.

  • The Fallacy of Casual ‘Human Involvement’: When lawyers defend the use of AI translation, they frequently point to the presence of a “human in the loop”. In AA, the witness’s daughter had reviewed the ChatGPT translation against the Arabic original. Yet as the case demonstrates, the mere fact that a bilingual relative, client employee, or junior staff member has looked over an AI translation tells a court nothing about their competence to identify subtle shifts in evidentiary certainty, omitted qualifications, or legal terminology. If a legal team misses an obvious English trace of ChatGPT on the face of a document, it has no credible basis for assuring a judge that the underlying foreign-language evidence has been reliably verified.

Professional Misconduct Findings Based on Unverified ChatGPT Translations: VA v JL [2025]

Even more concerning for legal practitioners is the New Zealand disciplinary decision in VA v JL [2025] NZLCRO 123, which arose from a client’s complaint regarding her lawyer’s handling of an employment and commercial dispute.

A central issue before the Legal Complaints Review Officer was whether the lawyer had misled her client by advising that commencing High Court proceedings could be used to halt or disrupt proceedings before the Employment Relations Authority. Crucially, the disputed advice was contained in chat messages exchanged between the lawyer and the client on 23 July 2021 in a foreign language (anonymised in the decision as “Language F”).

The client submitted a fuller record of the foreign-language chat exchange accompanied by English translations that the client stated she had generated using ChatGPT. In the ChatGPT-translated version, the lawyer was recorded as stating: “Yes, it will work” and “It does work! This is feasible!” The lawyer denied sending the disputed message and provided a shorter record with her own translations.

In making findings of unsatisfactory conduct against the lawyer, the Review Officer preferred the completeness of the client’s documentary record at paragraph [112] and expressly relied at paragraphs [208] and [209] on the statements “Yes, it will work” and “It does work! This is feasible!” when assessing the legal advice the lawyer had given. Yet nowhere in the published decision did the Review Officer explain how he established that the client’s ChatGPT translation accurately reflected the nuances of what had been written in Language F.

In legal advice concerning litigation strategy, the boundary between telling a client that a procedural route is theoretically possible and assuring the client that it will succeed turns on fine linguistic distinctions of modality and qualification. VA v JL serves as a stark warning to practising lawyers on two fronts. First, any foreign-language message you send to a client may subsequently be run through ChatGPT by that client and placed before a disciplinary tribunal as evidence of professional misconduct. Secondly, decision-makers who cannot read the source language may conflate the authenticity of a foreign-language record with the accuracy of its fluent English AI translation, treating unverified chatbot phrasing as proof of what a lawyer advised.

Confidentiality Breaches and the Vacuum of Vendor Liability

Beyond evidentiary and disciplinary perils in court, lawyers who upload client contracts, corporate disclosures, or pleadings into public machine translation or generative AI platforms face direct regulatory and contractual exposure. As Argyri Panezi and I examined in our paper for the International Conference on Machine Learning (Workshop on Generative AI and Law, ICML, 2023) and as the High Court of England and Wales emphasised in Ayinde v London Borough of Haringey [2025] EWHC 1383 regarding lawyers’ non-delegable supervisory duties over AI, practitioners remain bound by strict statutory duties of professional secrecy, UK and EU General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) obligations, and contractual Non-Disclosure Agreements (NDAs).

When an unverified AI translation causes financial loss or misses a statutory condition, the terms of service of every commercial AI and machine translation provider disclaim all warranties of accuracy and fitness for purpose. As I explored at the joint EULITA and PEEMPIP conference in Athens (Is Anyone Liable for Legal Translation?, 2024), technology vendors accept zero liability for the legal consequences of their outputs. The entire burden of professional negligence, regulatory sanction, and financial loss falls upon the instructing lawyer or corporate user who chose to rely on the machine.

6. Frequently Asked Questions

Has modern generative AI solved the legal translation errors seen in earlier tools like Google Translate?

No. While neural machine translation and generative AI models produce much smoother English sentences than statistical machine translation did ten years ago, empirical research shows that high fluency masks severe accuracy and terminological errors. Recent court decisions such as Lozano González v Roberge (where ChatGPT rewrote statutory provisions) and Euroboor BV v Grafova (where a US court struggled to understand a Google Translate rendering of a Dutch judgment) confirm that modern AI tools still fail to preserve legal meaning in contentious and transactional settings.

What are the risks to a lawyer who submits or relies on an AI-translated document in legal proceedings?

A lawyer who relies on or files an unverified AI translation risks judicial criticism for failing to check document provenance (as seen in AA v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2026] UKFTT PA747122024), file-level terminology drift across related contractual and litigation documents (as highlighted in Hellenic Supreme Court Judgment No. 221/2026), breaches of client confidentiality and GDPR obligations when uploading sensitive material to third-party servers, and full professional liability for any resulting loss. Furthermore, as VA v JL [2025] NZLCRO 123 illustrates, lawyers also face disciplinary risk when unverified ChatGPT translations of client communications are relied upon in professional conduct proceedings.

Is having a bilingual colleague or family member check a ChatGPT translation sufficient for legal purposes?

No. Reviewing an AI-generated translation against a foreign-language original requires specialist competence in both comparative law and legal translation. Empirical studies of machine translation post-editing (Sosoni, O’Shea & Stasimioti, 2022) demonstrate that the polished surface fluency of neural outputs anchors human reviewers, causing them to miss critical system-bound legal errors, omitted qualifications, and false equivalences between civil law and common law terminology.

7. Protecting Both Client and Counsel Through Specialist Lawyer-Linguist Expertise

The lesson of the past decade from KIP UK Ltd and Essential Telecom in 2016 to Hellenic Supreme Court Judgment No. 221/2026, AA v SSHD, and VA v JL in 2025 and 2026 is unmistakable: legal translation shapes the operative force of contracts, the admissibility of evidence, and the professional standing of legal advisers. Treating it as a zero-consequence mechanical task to be delegated to a probabilistic chatbot exposes both client and counsel to avoidable legal hazard.

Founded in 1997 in London and led by lawyer-linguist John O’Shea (LL.B. (Hons), LL.M.), JurTrans has spent nearly three decades providing specialist Greek-to-English and English-to-Greek legal and financial translation for international law firms, corporate legal departments, financial institutions, and private clients. Our practice is grounded in formal legal training, nearly thirty years of hands-on transactional and litigation experience across Greece, Cyprus, and the United Kingdom, and authoritative legal scholarship, including co-translating Greece’s foundational statutory codes (The Greek Penal Code, The Greek Code of Civil Procedure, The Greek Code of Criminal Procedure, and the Greek Code of Private Maritime Law) within the Lex Graeca series.

When you instruct JurTrans on a commercial contract, corporate finance transaction, regulatory filing, or cross-border litigation bundle, we protect both client and instructing counsel by ensuring:

  • From-Scratch Specialist Translation: Every document is translated from scratch by a qualified specialist without reliance on public machine translation or generative AI, eliminating the risk of algorithmic hallucinations and common law terminology bias.

  • File-Level Terminological Consistency: In multi-year commercial relationships and contentious proceedings, we cross-check new notices, pleadings, and exhibits against the terminology already established in your underlying agreements and court file.

  • Source-Text Detective Work: During 2024, across 946 Greek legal documents translated into English at JurTrans, we identified source-text errors, ambiguous statutory citations, or internal inconsistencies in approximately 95% of the originals. Rather than silently guessing or flattening an ambiguity, we preserve the integrity of the text and flag source-text defects directly for instructing counsel.

  • Strict Confidentiality and Accountability: All documents are handled under strict professional confidentiality and formal Non-Disclosure Agreements, backed by professional accountability that no AI vendor provides.

To discuss a Greek or Cypriot legal or financial translation requirement in complete confidence, contact John O’Shea at JurTrans via jurtrans.com or email info@jurtrans.com.

When a Greek court delivers a judgment, the parties involved naturally want to know what the court has decided and what happens next. For international clients who do not speak Greek, obtaining a clear and accurate English translation is often essential to understanding the outcome of the proceedings and discussing the implications with their Greek lawyers. The same applies to lawyers practising outside Greece who advise clients involved in Greek litigation. They may need to examine the judgment to understand the court’s reasoning, identify the issues decided and discuss the available options with the Greek legal team.

However, translating a Greek court judgment presents some distinctive challenges. Greek judicial decisions frequently contain lengthy and complex legal reasoning expressed in highly formal language. Procedural concepts may have no straightforward English equivalents, while apparently familiar terms can conceal important differences between legal systems. These problems become particularly significant when the judgment may be challenged on appeal or when the parties need to understand its consequences.

And with artificial intelligence now making it possible to generate an English translation or summary of a lengthy judgment in seconds, there is a further question: how much confidence can international clients and their lawyers place in the resulting text?

Understanding the structure of a Greek court judgment

Greek court judgments follow established drafting conventions which reflect the structure of Greek judicial reasoning and the procedural rules governing the proceedings. Depending on the court and type of proceedings, the judgment will ordinarily identify the court and parties, record relevant procedural information and set out the court’s reasoning before stating its decision. Two sections are especially important when translating a Greek judgment. The first is the σκεπτικό, the court’s reasoning, often introduced by the formula ΣΚΕΦΘΗΚΕ ΣΥΜΦΩΝΑ ΜΕ ΤΟ ΝΟΜΟ (having considered the matter in accordance with the law). This part of the judgment explains the legal basis on which the court has reached its conclusions. It may contain lengthy discussions of statutory provisions, references to case law and an examination of the parties’ arguments. The second is the διατακτικό, the operative part, commonly introduced by the expression ΓΙΑ ΤΟΥΣ ΛΟΓΟΥΣ ΑΥΤΟΥΣ (for these reasons). The operative part records the court’s decisions on the matters before it, including the disposition of claims and any orders made.

For a foreign reader, the relationship between these sections is fundamental to understanding what the judgment actually says.

The linguistic complexity of Greek judicial decisions

The language of Greek judgments presents difficulties that extend beyond specialised legal terminology. Greek judicial writing frequently employs long sentences containing multiple subordinate clauses. The syntax can be intricate, with qualifications and exceptions embedded within the same sentence as the principal legal proposition. In addition, some judicial formulations retain features of the older formal language associated with καθαρεύουσα, particularly in established expressions and conventional legal phraseology.

For translators working from Greek into English, these characteristics demand close attention to the grammatical and logical relationships within the text. The translator must establish precisely which proposition is being qualified, what a particular pronoun or participle refers to and whether a statement reflects the court’s conclusion or the position of one of the parties. These distinctions can become difficult to follow when a sentence extends over much of a paragraph. English legal writing generally permits a different approach to sentence construction. A lengthy Greek sentence may therefore need to be divided or restructured in English to make the reasoning intelligible. However, restructuring must preserve the original logical relationships. Careless division of a sentence can detach a qualification from the proposition to which it relates or alter the relationship between the court’s findings and its conclusions. This is where the ability to think and write like a lawyer becomes particularly valuable. Understanding the legal argument allows the translator to reconstruct it in clear English while preserving its precise meaning. The objective is an English text that a lawyer can read naturally and follow without losing any of the legal substance contained in the Greek original.

When is a Greek court judgment final?

One of the most revealing examples of the difficulties involved in translating Greek judgments concerns the terminology used to describe their procedural status. Consider the expression τελεσίδικη απόφαση. A reader encountering the English expression “final judgment” might reasonably assume that the judgment can no longer be challenged. Greek procedural law, however, recognises distinctions that make this apparently straightforward translation potentially misleading. In our paper Translating Greece’s Procedural Codes, presented at the 2023 conference of the Hellenic Society for Terminology, Daniel Webber and I examined the treatment of procedural terminology in existing Greek-English legal dictionaries. We found that all four dictionaries examined rendered τελεσίδικη απόφαση using variants of “final judgment” or “final decision”, without adequately reflecting the procedural distinctions recognised by Greek law. An οριστική απόφαση may be final in the sense that it disposes of the matter before the court, while remaining open to ordinary legal remedies. A τελεσίδικη απόφαση has reached a different procedural position, generally because the relevant ordinary legal remedies have been exhausted or the periods for exercising them have expired. Greek procedural law also recognises the category of ανέκκλητη απόφαση, concerning judgments which by their nature are not amenable to the relevant remedies, as well as αμετάκλητη απόφαση, which involves the exhaustion of available legal remedies, including the relevant avenues of recourse to higher courts.

For international clients, these distinctions can be important to understanding the procedural history of their case. They also illustrate the difficulties faced by foreign lawyers who may be familiar with the English word “final” but unfamiliar with the different categories recognised under Greek law. The translation needs to communicate the source terminology accurately without creating a misleading impression about the status of the decision. Determining whether a particular judgment can still be challenged, or what consequences follow from its procedural status, is a matter for the lawyers responsible for the proceedings.

Errors in the original Greek judgment: an overlooked translation problem

There is another difficulty which frequently arises in legal translation and which is easily overlooked by the end user: the original Greek document may itself contain errors. At JurTrans, our experience of translating Greek legal documents has made us particularly conscious of this problem. In an article published in January 2025, I reported that during 2024 we translated 946 Greek legal documents into English and found that approximately 95% contained at least one error of some kind. These figures relate to JurTrans’s own workload, which included various categories of legal documents. They should not be interpreted as a representative statistical study of the quality of Greek court judgments. Nevertheless, they illustrate how frequently source-text problems arise in our translation work. Some errors are relatively straightforward, while others require considerably more research to identify and understand. A judgment may refer to an incorrect article of legislation or contain an ambiguous statutory citation. There may also be inconsistencies in how a particular legal term is used. The translator must determine whether the apparent inconsistency has a reasonable explanation or whether there is a genuine problem in the Greek text.

In The legal translator as detective, I described an example from our translation work involving a reference to an article of the Greek Code of Civil Procedure. The provision cited in the document appeared to have no connection with the procedural steps being described. After checking the surrounding provisions and searching the Code, I eventually discovered that the reference related to an earlier version of the legislation. The source document had failed to make that historical context clear. Having identified the issue, I suggested that the instructing lawyer clarify the Greek wording. He agreed. The incident is a good illustration of the research that may be necessary to understand a legal text correctly. Given the successive amendments made to Greek legislation, consulting the current version of a statutory provision may sometimes be insufficient to establish the meaning of a historical reference.

Where a judgment contains an apparent error, the translator must preserve the integrity of the source text while drawing the issue to the attention of the instructing lawyer where appropriate. A careful translation process can therefore reveal problems which might otherwise remain unnoticed, particularly by clients who cannot consult the Greek original.

Why relying on AI-generated summaries of Greek judgments is risky

The ability to obtain an instant summary of a lengthy court judgment is understandably attractive. International clients may want an immediate answer to whether the proceedings have been successful, while foreign lawyers may need to understand the broad significance of a decision before speaking to their Greek counterparts. Generative AI systems appear to offer a convenient solution. A document can be uploaded and a short English summary requested in a matter of seconds. The difficulty lies in the reliability of that summary. Court judgments often depend on distinctions which can be lost when a lengthy text is compressed into a short narrative. A statutory exception may substantially qualify a legal proposition. The court may accept part of a party’s argument while rejecting another part. An apparently straightforward conclusion may depend on a particular interpretation of the facts or the application of a specific procedural rule. If a summary overlooks one of these qualifications, the reader may be left with an inaccurate understanding of the decision. There is also the risk that an automated system will fail to distinguish correctly between the parties’ submissions and the findings of the court. Greek judgments may reproduce the arguments advanced by litigants before explaining whether those arguments have been accepted. An AI-generated summary which attributes a rejected submission to the court would fundamentally misrepresent that part of the judgment.

These concerns are consistent with findings in the growing academic literature on automatic legal-document summarisation. In a 2024 study of large language models and generative systems for summarising court judgments, Aniket Deroy, Kripabandhu Ghosh and Saptarshi Ghosh examined systems using judgments from the supreme courts of the United Kingdom and India. Although generative systems performed relatively well according to conventional automatic evaluation metrics, closer examination identified inconsistencies in their summaries. The researchers concluded that further improvements were needed before such systems could be considered sufficiently reliable without detailed human checking. More recently, a 2026 review of legal-document summarisation research highlighted the difficulty of preserving the argumentative structure of judgments and the limitations of evaluation methods which primarily measure similarities in wording rather than legal accuracy.

Neither study, though, specifically evaluates Greek court judgments, but both identify problems relevant to the task of summarising complex judicial reasoning. The challenge is compounded when a Greek judgment is summarised directly into English. The system is then required to interpret the Greek legal text and produce a compressed account in another language, potentially concealing errors from readers who cannot independently verify the original.

For lawyers considering the implications of a judgment, a summary cannot provide the level of detail available in an accurate translation of the full text. The actual wording of the court’s reasoning may be central to understanding the decision and discussing possible further steps with Greek counsel.

What does research tell us about AI translation from Greek into English?

The limitations of automated translation in the Greek-English legal context have also been the subject of empirical research. In September 2026, Vilelmini Sosoni and I published a chapter in Springer’s International Handbook of Legal Language and Communication entitled Translating Normative Legal Texts: A Comparative Evaluation of Neural Machine Translation and Generative Artificial Intelligence Models in the Greek-English Language Pair. The study compared a neural machine translation system trained on legal-domain material with three generative AI models. We evaluated translations of two Greek property law texts, comprising planning legislation and a property sale agreement, using automatic translation-quality metrics alongside detailed human error analysis. Our findings were revealing. Accuracy errors predominated across the systems examined, and most were classified as major in severity. Although the generated English generally displayed adequate fluency, the generative AI models did not systematically outperform the specialist neural machine translation system.

These findings concern normative legal texts rather than court judgments. Their significance for the present discussion lies in the difficulties the systems encountered when translating specialised Greek legal concepts into English. The results reinforce the need to distinguish between an English text that reads fluently and one that faithfully communicates the legal meaning of its Greek source. A system may produce entirely natural English while selecting an inappropriate equivalent for a Greek procedural concept or failing to preserve an important qualification. Recognising such problems requires detailed knowledge of the source legal system and the ability to evaluate the translation against the original. Technology certainly has useful applications in legal translation, particularly in supporting research and maintaining terminological resources. However, the limitations identified in empirical studies call for considerable caution when using AI or machine translation to communicate the substance of court judgments.

At JurTrans, our approach to documents of this nature is based on establishing the meaning of the Greek text through specialist legal-linguistic analysis and producing an English translation whose accuracy can be carefully verified against the source.

Preparing Greek judgments and appeal documents for international readers

The usefulness of a Greek-English legal translation also depends on understanding the circumstances in which it will be read. For a Greek lawyer representing an international client, the primary objective may be to enable that client to understand the court’s decision and participate meaningfully in discussions about the case. Lawyers practising outside Greece may require more detailed access to the reasoning, particularly where the litigation has implications for their client’s commercial activities or wider legal affairs. In either situation, the translator benefits from understanding the purpose of the assignment. Where a judgment refers extensively to previous decisions or procedural documents, access to those materials may assist with the interpretation of terminology and the maintenance of consistency across the translations. The English text should also enable the reader to locate the corresponding material in the Greek original. This requires attention to the document’s structure, the identification of the parties and the reproduction of references to legislation and earlier decisions. Where only selected passages are translated, the extent of the translation should be clearly identified so that the reader is aware of the material covered. However, where the purpose is to understand the judgment as a whole, a complete translation is generally more useful than an abbreviated account which may omit context essential to the court’s reasoning. The appropriate scope should be agreed with the instructing lawyer, who remains responsible for determining how the translated document will be used in connection with the proceedings.

The value of specialist Greek-English legal translation expertise

At JurTrans, we have specialised in Greek-English legal and financial translation for three decades. Our work involves examining legal documents within their procedural and substantive context, with particular attention to terminology whose meaning depends on the structure of the Greek legal system. That experience is supported by formal legal education, university-level teaching experience and sustained involvement in academic research into legal translation.

Through our work on the Lex Graeca project, including the translation of major Greek codes (both substantive and procedural) into English, we have also developed extensive experience in researching Greek legal terminology and establishing consistent English renderings of concepts which are often inadequately covered by existing reference works.

We have translated many millions of words over those decades and have countless satisfied clients.  These figures reflect the depth of experience accumulated across a broad range of legal assignments.

Our approach to translating Greek court judgments is informed by detailed familiarity with the intricacies of Greek law and an appreciation of how the English translation will be understood by lawyers accustomed to different legal systems.

We approach each text with the analytical mindset of a lawyer, examining the reasoning and procedural context before settling on the most appropriate English terminology. Equally important is close attention to detail. Statutory references are checked where necessary, potential inconsistencies are investigated and questions arising from the Greek original are raised with the instructing lawyer when clarification is required. This is supported by specialist legal reference resources, access to current legal databases and a commitment to the confidentiality of clients’ documents.

For international clients and their legal advisers, the objective is to provide an English translation which communicates the substance of the Greek judgment faithfully and allows the legal issues to be discussed on an informed basis.

 

Frequently asked questions about translating Greek court judgments

Does a Greek court judgment need to be translated in full?

The appropriate scope depends on why the translation is required. Where an international client or foreign lawyer needs to understand the complete reasoning and outcome of the proceedings, a full translation is generally the most useful option. Translations of selected passages may also be appropriate, provided their scope is clearly identified and agreed with the instructing lawyer.

 

Can AI summarise a Greek judgment accurately?

AI-generated summaries may provide preliminary orientation, but their reliability should not be assumed. Research into automated judgment summarisation has identified factual inconsistencies, while studies of Greek-English legal translation have found substantial accuracy errors in automated outputs. Where a judgment’s meaning is important, the original text and an accurate professional translation provide a more dependable basis for legal discussion.

What should be provided when commissioning a Greek court judgment translation?

Providing the complete Greek document and, where relevant, earlier decisions or existing translations can help the translator understand the procedural context and maintain consistent terminology. It is also useful to explain who will read the translation and whether particular cross-references or presentation requirements need to be preserved.

Greek court judgment and appeal translation services at JurTrans

Greek court judgments and appeals can be demanding documents to translate. Their legal meaning depends on the procedural context, the structure of judicial reasoning and the specialised terminology of Greek law.

For international clients and the lawyers advising them, an accurate English translation provides the basis for understanding what the Greek court has decided and discussing its significance with the Greek legal team.

JurTrans provides specialist Greek-English translation of court judgments, appeal documents and related litigation materials, drawing on decades of practical experience and academic research into legal language.

If you require an English translation of a Greek court judgment or documents relating to an appeal, please contact JurTrans or email info@jurtrans.com.

JurTrans is a specialist legal translation company and does not provide legal advice. This article addresses legal translation and communication issues for general information. Questions concerning legal rights, procedural remedies and the consequences of court decisions should be addressed to the lawyers responsible for the proceedings.

 

 

“This paper has shown that GenAI is not fully capable of identifying terms that may be ambiguous for readers; consequently, its ability to define or explain such elements is limited. Likewise, its aptitude to ‘choose familiar, legally accurate words’ is also compromised, especially in view of the training-based nature of its responses.

Indeed, the six chatbots under scrutiny did not show the ability to interpret legal terms in context and legal subtleties accurately. Users need certainty and clarity when addressing legal concepts.

Therefore, chatbots are currently unsuitable for the easification or disambiguation of legal communication and making it understandable and usable for its intended audience.

Although AI may seem to provide sensible responses, inexactness and approximation come to the fore when analysing outputs in detail. This means that AI-generated responses are not reliable and consistent, as they can differ from one query to another.”

Giampieri, P., “Can GenAI identify and disambiguate legal polysemous terminology? a critical analysis in light of ISO 24495-2:2025 on legal communication” (2026) Iura & Legal Systems

 

#LegalTranslation #LegalConcepts #GenAI #Accuracy #LegalLanguage

“In legal contexts, translation does not merely convey information; it can shape the operative force of a document. If a machine translation changes the scope of a clause, weakens a condition, or substitutes a general term for a legally defined one, the translated text may carry a different normative effect from the source text.

This problem is especially serious in legally binding texts such as contracts, regulations, and judgments, where the translated version may be relied upon for legal interpretation or enforcement.

Machine learning systems are not inherently aware of these consequences, because they optimise for probabilistic plausibility rather than legal equivalence. accuracy is inseparable from the goal of achieving an equivalent, uniform legal effect. Unlike general or literary translation, legal translation operates within tightly constrained systems of meaning shaped by jurisdiction-specific norms, institutional practices, and codified terminology.

A mistranslation in this domain is not merely a semantic error; it can alter rights, obligations, and legal outcomes, potentially leading to financial loss, contractual disputes, or miscarriages of justice.”

 

#LawyersOfLinkedin #AI #MT #AlteredMeaning

 

Pinčić, Domagoj & Bajcic, Martina. (2026). Challenges of the Legal Translation Task in the Context of Machine Learning. 10.5281/zenodo.22765851.

“Legal translation is widely recognised as a high-stakes, domain-specific activity in which linguistic accuracy is inseparable from the goal of achieving an equivalent, uniform legal effect. Unlike general or literary translation, legal translation operates within tightly constrained systems of meaning shaped by jurisdiction-specific norms, institutional practices, and codified terminology. A mistranslation in this domain is not merely a semantic error; it can alter rights, obligations, and legal outcomes, potentially leading to financial loss, contractual disputes, or miscarriages of justice.”

Pinčić, Domagoj & Bajcic, Martina. (2026). Challenges of the Legal Translation Task in the Context of Machine Learning. 10.5281/zenodo.22765851.

#lawyersOfLinkedin #rights #AI #MT

Ορισμένες πρώτες σκέψεις σχετικά με την απόφαση 221/2026 του Αρείου Πάγου.

Η υπόθεση αφορούσε ένα μακροχρόνιο έργο αιολικής ενέργειας, στο οποίο συμμετείχαν μια ελληνική εταιρεία ανάπτυξης έργων και ένας Ισπανός επενδυτής. Παρότι το έργο επρόκειτο να κατασκευαστεί στην Ελλάδα, η μεταξύ τους σχέση διεπόταν από συμβάσεις συνταγμένες στην αγγλική γλώσσα.

Όταν η σχέση αυτή οδηγήθηκε τελικά σε ρήξη, ο Ισπανός επενδυτής επέδωσε εξώδικη δήλωση με την οποία γνωστοποιούσε ότι είχε αποφασίσει να «terminate the … Contracts and withdraw from the Project».

Η έννοια και οι έννομες συνέπειες της δήλωσης αυτής αποτέλεσαν αντικείμενο της δίκης. Τα δικαστήρια που εξέτασαν την υπόθεση ασχολήθηκαν με το συμβατικό λεκτικό και τις ελληνικές μεταφράσεις.

Για περισσότερα, διαβάστε το άρθρο. ⬇️ Greek Supreme Court judgment No. 221/2026

 

Hellenic Supreme Court Judgment No. 221/2026 [1] contains an unusually useful example of translation becoming part of the legal problem in a cross-border dispute.

The underlying case concerned a long- running wind-energy project involving a Greek developer and a Spanish investor. Their relationship was governed by English-language contracts. When that relationship eventually broke down, the Spanish investor served an extrajudicial notice stating that it had decided to “terminate the … Contracts and withdraw from the Project”. The meaning and legal effect of that declaration became part of the litigation. The courts had to consider the contractual language, the Greek translations relied upon by the parties and the legal mechanism that the notice was attempting to exercise

The way the documents had been translated had become relevant to the court’s legal analysis of the dispute.

When terminology becomes part of the argument

The central translation issue concerned the English terms “withdrawal” and “withdraw”. The parties had produced different Greek renderings of the same contractual language. In the Framework Agreement, the Greek developer translated the heading “Withdrawal” as «Υπαναχώρηση». The Spanish investor’s translation used «Απόσυρση». Within the operative provisions of the Spanish investor’s own translation, however, “withdraw from their obligations” was rendered using «υπαναχώρηση», and the same term appeared again in the provisions describing the consequences of exercising that right. The Court of Appeal expressly identified the inconsistency.

That finding has an immediate practical significance for lawyers. A translation commissioned during the early stages of a matter may still be sitting in the file several years later when the meaning of the underlying provision becomes disputed. The terminology adopted at that earlier stage can then be compared with later translations of notices, correspondence, pleadings and exhibits. If the same contractual mechanism has been rendered differently across the record, counsel may have to explain why. In Judgment No. 221/2026, the inconsistency was visible to the court and formed part of its assessment of the competing terminology.

The legal significance of the words also depended on context. The Court of Appeal considered «υπαναχώρηση», «απόσυρση» and «αποχώρηση» in light of the contractual mechanism created by the relevant provisions and the legal consequences attached to it. It concluded that, in this particular contractual setting, “withdrawal” and “withdraw” were to be understood from the viewpoint of Greek law as «υπαναχώρηση» and «υπαναχωρώ». That reasoning is useful precisely because it is contextual. An English verb that appears straightforward at first sight may acquire a much narrower legal significance once it is placed inside a clause dealing with the exercise of a particular contractual right.

For counsel, this creates a clear risk-management issue. A translation can contain language that is perfectly intelligible and still create difficulty because the chosen terminology does not sit coherently with the legal mechanism expressed elsewhere in the contract. The problem becomes more serious where several translations have been commissioned at different times and the terminology has drifted. Once the dispute reaches court, those choices become part of the documentary history of the case.

Terminology drift

Cross-border disputes rarely arrive fully formed. They develop over time[2]. An agreement may be translated when advice is first sought. Correspondence may be translated months later. An extrajudicial notice may be prepared during an escalation of the dispute. Pleadings, exhibits and witness material may follow. Appeals and cassation proceedings can generate further translation requirements. The same underlying contractual concepts may therefore reappear in documents produced years apart.

That makes translation consistency a case-management issue. The important question is whether recurring concepts have been treated coherently across the file. Counsel should know how a key term was translated in the agreement, whether the same terminology was used in subsequent correspondence, and whether a later translation introduces a different Greek expression for the same contractual mechanism. If a change is deliberate, it should be capable of explanation. If it has happened accidentally because a later document was translated without access to the earlier material, the file has acquired an avoidable vulnerability[3].

Judgment No. 221/2026 gives this point real substance. The court did not examine one translated sentence in isolation. It moved across the Framework Agreement, the Project Agreement, the parties’ respective translations and the December 2015 notice. Earlier terminology informed the analysis of the later declaration. The documents formed a chain. For lawyers managing a bilingual dispute, the translation process needs to reflect that same chain.

This has implications for the way instructions are given. A translator dealing with an operative notice may need the underlying agreement and its existing translation. A translator working on pleadings may need to see the terminology already adopted in the evidence. Where a concept is genuinely ambiguous, counsel may need to decide how that ambiguity should be handled before the translation is finalised. Those steps reduce the chance that terminology will develop independently across documents that will ultimately be read together.

The legal effect of a few words

The December 2015 notice brought these issues into focus. Its English text stated that the Spanish investor had decided to “terminate the … Contracts and withdraw from the Project”. The Court of Appeal considered that the wording raised a question about the juridical character of the declaration, because the two expressions potentially pointed towards different legal mechanisms.

The court then examined the consequences contemplated by the notice. Among other things, the Spanish investor proposed the transfer of its shares in the project company for a nominal price. That consequence corresponded with the contractual mechanism provided for in Article 5.2 of the Framework Agreement in connection with withdrawal. The court therefore characterised the declaration as an exercise of contractual υπαναχώρηση.

For a lawyer reviewing a translation, this is an important point of method. Operative language has to be read through the legal function of the document. A notice may be exercising a right, triggering a contractual consequence or attempting to bring a legal relationship to an end. A translation choice affecting the characterisation of that act deserves a different level of scrutiny from a purely descriptive passage in the factual record.

That distinction is easy to miss where the disputed English word appears ordinary and is not a term of art. “Withdraw” is common language. In this case, it was connected with a contractual right carrying defined conditions and consequences. A translator who treats the word as an isolated lexical problem may produce a fluent version while missing the legal architecture around it. Counsel then inherits that decision when the document is relied upon in proceedings.

The judgment provides another example in the word “feasibility”. Article 3.5 of the Project Agreement referred to the project’s “technical and financial feasibility”. One translation rendered the term as «βιωσιμότητα». The Court of Appeal considered «σκοπιμότητα» the appropriate rendering in the context of the provision.

The point is useful because “feasibility” does not immediately look like a difficult legal term. Within Article 3.5, however, it formed part of the condition governing whether the investor could exercise its right to withdraw from the project. Its importance came from the work it was doing in the clause.

Commercial contracts contain many expressions of this kind. “Material”, “reasonable”, “completion”, “default”, “acceptance”, “notice”, “cause” and similar words can acquire considerable significance through their contractual function. Their translation requires attention to the surrounding rights, obligations and consequences. The presence of familiar vocabulary should not encourage a lighter review where the clause itself performs important legal work.

For counsel, the practical implication is straightforward. Review effort should follow legal significance. A term embedded in a provision governing termination, withdrawal, liability, payment, default or another important contractual mechanism deserves close attention even if the English itself appears routine.

The risk often lies in the relationship between the word and the clause, not in the word viewed on its own.

AI does not remove the need for file-level verification

The same issue arises when machine translation or generative AI is incorporated into the workflow. Glossaries and terminology instructions can improve consistency across large volumes of material. They are useful tools, particularly where a case contains recurring technical or contractual language. Their effectiveness still needs to be verified against the documents that matter.

Generative systems produce language probabilistically. A preferred term may be supplied in a glossary and still appear differently in another passage. The system may preserve the chosen word while misunderstanding the legal relationship expressed by the clause. Large-scale use therefore creates a practical review question for counsel: have the legally significant occurrences actually been checked against the agreement and against the terminology already used elsewhere in the file?

That question becomes particularly important where translation work is divided across several stages of a dispute. An AI-assisted translation of a new notice may be linguistically polished and internally coherent while departing from terminology established years earlier in the contract. Without a case-level review, the divergence may remain invisible until the documents are placed side by side in proceedings.

Translation risk

Judgment No. 221/2026 does not support the claim that the Spanish investor lost because of a bad translation. After the December notice had been characterised as an exercise of υπαναχώρηση, the courts still had to determine whether the contractual conditions for exercising that right had been met. Article 3.5 allowed withdrawal where the project’s technical or financial feasibility had proved insufficient under the relevant conditions. The Court of Appeal found that the notice did not specify whether the alleged inadequacy was technical, economic or both, and did not identify the supporting data. The attempted exercise of the right therefore failed on substantive grounds. The Supreme Court rejected the cassation challenge to that conclusion.

The translation issue nevertheless mattered because it formed part of the route by which the legal act was characterised. That is a realistic model of translation risk in contentious work. The danger is often cumulative. An inconsistent term, an unexamined synonym, a later document translated without reference to the underlying agreement, or an ordinary commercial word carrying an important contractual threshold can create an additional point requiring submissions and judicial analysis.

Cross-border litigation already contains enough genuine uncertainty. Translation should be managed so that it does not introduce further avoidable ambiguity into the record. Judgment No. 221/2026 shows how easily terminology can become part of the forensic material once a dispute turns on the legal effect of the documents themselves. For Greek lawyers working with English-language contracts, the case offers a practical reason to treat translated terminology as part of the case strategy from the outset, with the same attention to consistency, context and legal consequence that is applied to the original documents.

 

Litigation and contractual translation services at JurTrans

As Hellenic Supreme Court Judgment No. 221/2026 illustrates, commercial disputes often span years of agreements, correspondence, extrajudicial notices and court filings. Maintaining terminological consistency across those documents is essential if the translated record is to reflect the underlying contractual mechanisms accurately. At JurTrans, we have provided specialist Greek-English legal and financial translation services to Greek and international law firms for nearly three decades.

Led by John O’Shea (LL.B., LL.M.), we translate commercial contracts, extrajudicial declarations, pleadings, exhibits and Greek court judgments with close attention to file-level consistency and the existing terminology of the dispute. By cross-checking operative clauses against the wider documentary record and raising source-text queries with instructing counsel where appropriate, we help legal teams rely on their English and Greek translations with confidence. If you need translation support for cross-border litigation, arbitration or commercial contracts involving Greece or Cyprus, please contact Jurtans at info@jurtrans.com

JurTrans is a specialist legal translation company and does not provide legal advice. This article discusses translation issues arising from published case law for general information only.

#GreekLaw #LegalTranslation #ContractualDisputes

[1] https://shorturl.at/f0m4s. The judgment is in Greek.

[2] Scott, J., O’Shea, J. How Legal Documents Translated Outside Institutions Affect Lives, Businesses and the Economy. Int J Semiot Law 34, 1331–1373 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11196-020-09815-5

[3] Scott, J. & O’Shea, J., ‘Legal Systems Exposed: Translation and Vulnerabilities’ in Anne Wagner and Aleksandra Matulewska (eds), Research Handbook on Jurilinguistics (Edward Elgar Publishing 2023) 300 https://doi.org/10.4337/9781802207248.00029

I recently read a paper that got me thinking about the way ambiguity operates in legal texts, and in particular about what happens to that ambiguity when a text is translated into another language. Many of the points it raises are familiar from legal practice, but they take on an added significance in legal translation, where a choice of words can also become a choice between competing legal interpretations.

In Ambiguities in Normative Texts and Their Resolution in the Rule of Law[1], Pierre Moor argues that ambiguity is an unavoidable feature of legal systems. Legal rules are expressed through ordinary language, applied to facts that are often uncertain, and expected to govern situations that legislators cannot fully anticipate. Ambiguity therefore arises at several stages: in establishing what happened, in interpreting the legal text, and in deciding whether a particular set of facts falls within a legal concept. Courts are required to resolve these uncertainties and to justify the reasoning by which they do so.

The paper is a useful read for anyone interested in legal translation because it explains, from the perspective of legal theory, why difficult legal texts are difficult in the first place. For lawyers commissioning translations, including translations from Greek into English, many of the most challenging problems arise where language, legal concepts, factual circumstances and institutional practice interact. A translator may be able to identify a plausible English equivalent for every Greek word in a sentence and still face a serious question about what the provision means in law, how broad the relevant concept is, or whether the source text deliberately leaves room for more than one interpretation.

Moor’s discussion of legal language is particularly relevant here. He points out that legal norms have to be communicated through ordinary language and therefore inherit the ambiguities of ordinary language. Legal concepts are expressed through words, but their application depends on whether a particular real-world situation falls within the category represented by those words. His example of a “forest” makes the point clearly. Everyone has a general understanding of what a forest is, but a legal rule protecting forests immediately raises further questions when applied to a particular wooded area. Its size, ecological role, composition and place in the landscape may all become relevant to determining whether it is a “forest” for the purposes of the legislation. The difficulty lies in the legal scope of the category, and that difficulty remains present when the term is translated into another language.

This has an important consequence for legal translation. Ambiguity in a source text may be legally significant and may need to survive the translation. A translator who renders the provision in broader terms may produce fluent English, but would also have made a substantive interpretative choice about the scope of the rule. In litigation, arbitration, regulatory proceedings or contractual disputes, a choice of that kind may matter considerably.

Moor’s idea of “normative density” is also useful for thinking about translation. Some legal concepts are relatively precise and lend themselves more readily to deductive application. Others, including concepts such as “fault”, “just cause” and “public interest”, require an assessment of the circumstances and cannot be applied mechanically. The lower the normative density of a concept, the more room there is for judgment about whether the facts fall within it. The same distinction affects translation. A tightly defined procedural term may have a relatively stable rendering in English, whereas an open-ended concept may depend heavily on the statutory context, the relevant case law and the legal culture in which it operates. This is particularly important where the source and target languages belong to different legal traditions.

Greek-to-English legal translation illustrates the problem well. English terminology carries its own legal associations, and an apparently obvious English equivalent may suggest doctrines, procedures or institutional arrangements that are different from those of Greek law. The issue becomes especially acute with terms that have familiar-looking English counterparts. A translation may read smoothly and convincingly while leading an English-speaking lawyer towards a concept derived from English law rather than the concept operating in the Greek source. Careful translation therefore requires attention to the legal function of a term within its source system, the purpose of the document and the expectations of the intended reader. Depending on the context, the best solution may be a conventional functional equivalent, a more literal rendering that avoids importing unwanted associations, or an explanatory formulation.

The paper also helps to clarify the relationship between translation and interpretation. Moor’s judges are constantly engaged in interpretation because legal texts do not always determine their own application. When ambiguity exists, the judge must choose between possible readings and provide reasons for that choice. Moor distinguishes between arguments drawn from within the legal system and arguments that draw on wider social knowledge, political culture, experience and ideas of fairness. Translators also make interpretative decisions, although their institutional role is very different. A judge has authority to resolve a legal ambiguity. A translator generally does not. For that reason, where several interpretations of a source expression are genuinely possible, considerable care is required before the translation silently commits the reader to one of them. Preserving the ambiguity, choosing terminology that leaves the question open, or alerting the instructing lawyer to the issue may be preferable, depending on the purpose of the translation.

This is also where current enthusiasm for AI in legal translation needs to be treated with caution. AI may be useful for generating an initial draft, suggesting terminology, comparing possible formulations or identifying passages that deserve closer attention. It does not remove the interpretative problems described by Moor. A language model may produce a seemingly highly fluent English version of a difficult legal passage while obscuring the fact that the source admits more than one reading. It may choose the most statistically or linguistically plausible interpretation without recognising that the ambiguity itself carries legal significance. It can also select an English legal term that appears semantically close while importing concepts associated with a different legal system. In that sense, fluency can make the problem harder to detect, because the resulting text may appear authoritative and settled even where the source is neither.

AI also cannot supply the institutional judgment that Moor describes. His account of legal reasoning depends on context, legal authority, argumentation and an understanding of how a particular legal system treats an open-textured concept. An LLM may help retrieve or organise relevant information, but the decision that a Greek term should be translated in one way rather than another may ultimately depend on the purpose of the translation, the procedural setting, the surrounding legislation, relevant case law and the consequences of choosing one interpretation over another. These are questions that require legal and translational judgement. The greater the ambiguity of the source and the greater the legal consequences of resolving it, the less sensible it is to treat machine-generated fluency as evidence that the underlying problem has been solved.

Moor’s broader conclusion is that ambiguity has a legitimate place within law because it allows legal rules to remain responsive to circumstances that could not have been fully anticipated when they were drafted. That conclusion has an important implication for anyone commissioning a legal translation. Quality cannot be assessed only by the smoothness of the English or by whether each source-language term appears to have received a neat equivalent. A good legal translation must also preserve the distinctions, uncertainties and interpretative possibilities that matter in the source legal system. In difficult cases, some of the awkwardness belongs to the law itself.

For lawyers dealing with complex cross-border matters, Moor’s paper is therefore useful well beyond its immediate subject. It provides a theoretical explanation for something experienced legal translators encounter in practice every day: legal meaning does not sit neatly inside individual words waiting to be transferred from one language to another. It emerges from the relationship between text, legal concepts, facts, institutions and interpretation. Any translation process, whether human or AI-assisted, that overlooks those relationships risks producing English that is perfectly readable and legally wrong.

 

How JurTrans approaches complex Greek-English legal translation

When commissioning a translation of a Greek contract, statute or pleading, the instructing lawyer needs confidence that the English version neither flattens deliberate statutory ambiguity nor introduces unintended common law associations. JurTrans is a boutique legal and financial translation company founded in 1997 by John O’Shea (LL.B., LL.M.), providing specialist Greek-to-English and English-to-Greek translation services for law firms, businesses and international clients.

Because our work is grounded in formal legal education and nearly three decades of practical translation experience across Greek and Cypriot law, we examine each document within its procedural and statutory setting before settling on the appropriate English rendering. Where a Greek provision is open to more than one reading or contains a potential source-text inconsistency, we preserve the integrity of the original and flag the issue for the instructing lawyers so they can assess its legal implications. To discuss a Greek or Cypriot legal translation requirement, please contact Jurtrans at info@jurtrans.com

JurTrans is a specialist legal translation company and does not provide legal advice. Questions concerning the legal interpretation or consequences of a document should be addressed to qualified legal counsel.

 

[1] Moor, P. (2026). Ambiguities in Normative Texts and Their Resolution in the Rule of Law. In: Wagner, A. (eds) International Handbook of Legal Language and Communication. Springer, Cham. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-87993-7_89-1Why ambiguity matters in legal translation

You’ve found a property in Greece. The contract arrives. It’s twenty pages of dense Greek text, notarial stamps, legal terminology you don’t recognise. You open ChatGPT or Google Translate, paste in a section, and get back what looks like fluent English sentences that seem to make sense.

Can you rely on this to understand what you’re signing?

The short answer: online tools can help you get the gist of an email or a brief description, but they’re not enough to rely on for a something as important as a binding property contract. The risks aren’t theoretical. They’re concrete, costly, and entirely avoidable.

Can’t I just use AI translation for my Greek property contract?

What artificial translation tools actually do

I use the term artificial translation for machine translation and generative AI tools that work by predicting the most statistically likely word or phrase based on patterns in vast amounts of text data. They don’t understand meaning generally. They don’t know law in particular. They especially don’t know or understand Greek property law. They optimise for fluency, producing output that reads smoothly in English. They do not aim for legal accuracy.

The tools are indeed fast, free, and useful for getting a rough sense of texts written in a general language. That’s their strength. But those same characteristics become limitations when you’re dealing with legal documents. Tools like these have no legal training. They accept no liability for errors in the output. They don’t understand your specific transaction, the Greek legal system the document comes from, or the legal system you’re familiar with in your home country. They can’t assess how you might interpret a legal concept based on your own jurisdiction’s framework, and they certainly won’t flag when a Greek legal term doesn’t map neatly onto an English equivalent.

The special features of Greek property contracts

Greek property contracts aren’t simple agreements. They’re long, dense notarial deeds with formulaic but highly complex legal and procedural language and very particular terminology. The structure is standardised, but the content varies significantly depending on the property, its history, and the transaction terms.

A typical contract includes a detailed description of the property, often referencing cadastral numbers, boundaries, and adjoining properties. It sets out the ownership history: who owned the property previously and how title passed. It lists encumbrances: mortgages, prenotations, easements, rights of way, planning restrictions. It includes declarations by the seller about the property’s legal status, tax compliance, and any pending disputes. It specifies payment terms, penalties for breach, and conditions that must be met before completion. If the property is part of a building with multiple owners, the contract incorporates co-ownership rules governing shared spaces, maintenance obligations, and decision-making, among other things.

Small wording differences in these sections can have significant consequences. A mistranslation of a condition precedent could mean you think a payment is due on signing when it’s actually due only after a specific event occurs. An error in describing an encumbrance could leave you unaware that a third party has legal rights over part of your property.

Accountability

One of the core risks of using artificial translation tools for your contract is there is no accountability if something goes wrong.

Artificial translation tools explicitly disclaim responsibility for errors. Their terms of service make clear that outputs are provided “as is” without warranties of accuracy, completeness, or fitness for any particular purpose. If you rely on an AI-generated translation and sign a contract based on a misunderstanding caused by a mistranslation, you have no recourse against the tool provider. Whether that’s right or not is a different matter. It is what their terms of service state.

You as the buyer carry the risk. If the mistranslation means you didn’t understand a key obligation and you breach the contract as a result, you’re liable for the penalties specified in the Greek text regardless of what the artificially-generated translation led you to believe.

Contrast this with working with a professional translator.

A specialist legal translator has professional duties: to translate accurately, to flag ambiguities, to maintain confidentiality, to apply appropriate expertise.

Many carry professional indemnity insurance. If an error occurs, there’s a clear accountability trail and a mechanism for addressing the problem. That doesn’t eliminate risk entirely, but it certainly distributes it more appropriately than placing the entire burden on you as a non-Greek-speaking buyer trying to assess a document you can’t verify.

When artificial translation can still be useful

Artificial translation isn’t useless.

It’s useful for “gist only” purposes: skimming a short email from an estate agent to understand the general topic before you reply, getting a very rough sense of a property listing to decide whether it’s worth pursuing, checking the broad content of a brief document before you send it to a professional.

The key is recognising the limitation.

These tools give you a rough approximation. They help you orient yourself. They don’t give you reliable information to base decisions on.

If you’re using artificial translation to get a rough sense of a document, that’s fine, as long as any actual decision-making is based on a proper human translation and legal advice.

Use the AI output to decide whether to pursue the property. Don’t use it to decide whether to sign the contract.

What a specialist human translator adds

A specialist Greek-to-English legal translator brings deep familiarity with Greek property terminology and notarial style. They know how υποθήκη differs from προσημείωση, how επικαρπία works under Greek law, what οριζόντια ιδιοκτησία entails in practice. They recognise formulaic phrasing and know which variations matter legally and which are just stylistic.

They can resolve ambiguities. When a Greek clause could be read two ways, a specialist translator applies legal knowledge and context to determine the intended meaning, then renders it clearly in English. If genuine ambiguity remains (if the Greek text itself is unclear, which it often is I my experience),  they flag it so you can seek clarification before signing.

They ensure consistency across all related documents. A Greek property transaction typically involves multiple documents: the main contract, powers of attorney, land registry extracts, cadastral certificates, co-ownership rules if the property is part of a building, tax clearance certificates. Terms and concepts need to be translated consistently across all these documents so you can understand how they relate to each other. If one document refers to a δουλεία (easement) and another mentions a δικαίωμα διόδου (right of way), you need to know whether these are the same encumbrance described differently or two separate rights. A specialist translator maintains that consistency and explains the relationships.

They collaborate with your lawyer. A good legal translator doesn’t just produce an English text and disappear. They’re available to answer follow-up questions, to explain why a particular term was translated a certain way, to clarify Greek legal concepts that don’t have direct English equivalents. If your lawyer spots something in the translation that needs clarification, the translator can go back to the Greek text, re-examine the context, and provide a more detailed explanation. That collaboration ensures the translation supports your legal advice rather than creating confusion.

A safe, realistic workflow for foreign buyers

Here’s a practical approach that uses artificial translation tools where they are helpful without exposing you to unnecessary risk:

Step one: Use artificial translation, if you wish, to get the broad context of emails or short texts from estate agents, sellers, or other parties. This helps you stay informed and respond promptly to routine communications.

Step two: Send the full Greek contract and all related documents to a specialist legal translator. Don’t try to translate only the “important” parts yourself. You can’t reliably identify which parts are important without understanding the whole document, and Greek contracts are structured so that critical information appears throughout, not just in obvious sections.

Step three: Have your own lawyer review the professional translation. Ideally, instruct a Greek lawyer who understands the local legal context and can verify that the contract protects your interests under Greek law. If you’re also working with a lawyer in your home country, share the translation with them so they can advise on any cross-border implications or help you understand Greek legal concepts in terms you’re familiar with, and interact with the Greek lawyer to do so if needs be.

Step four: Use follow-up questions to clarify any terms you still don’t understand before signing. If the translation includes a term like “horizontal property ownership” or “usufruct” and you’re not sure what practical obligations this creates for you, ask. A good translator or lawyer will explain it in plain language until you’re confident you understand what you’re agreeing to.

This workflow takes longer than pasting text into an online tool and signing based on the output. But it ensures you actually understand the contract you’re signing, which is the entire point.

Questions foreign buyers often ask

“Can I sign based on an artificially-translated summary my agent gave me?”

No. Your agent’s interests aren’t identical to yours. Basically, they want the sale to complete. Even if the agent is acting in good faith, they’re not qualified to assess the legal accuracy of an artificial translation or to identify risks that matter specifically to you. Get your own independent translation and legal advice.

“Is it enough to translate only the ‘important’ parts?”

No. You can’t reliably identify which parts are important without understanding the whole document. Critical obligations, conditions, and encumbrances appear throughout Greek property contracts, not just in sections with obvious headings. A restriction buried in a paragraph about property description might matter more than an entire section on standard warranties.

“What if my budget is tight? Can I translate just the first draft?”

If budget is a constraint, prioritise getting a professional translation of the final contract before you sign. Don’t spend money on translating draft versions unless there are specific clauses you need to negotiate and you need to understand the Greek wording to do that effectively. But the final version you’re actually signing must be professionally translated. The cost of translation is a small fraction of the property price and an even smaller fraction of the cost of discovering after completion that you misunderstood a key term.

“Do I really need both a lawyer and a translator?”

Yes. They do different things. The translator converts the Greek text into accurate English so you can read, and more importantly, understand it. The lawyer advises you on what the contract means legally, whether it protects your interests, what risks it creates, and what you should negotiate. You need to understand the document (translation) and you need to understand whether signing it is a good idea (legal advice). One doesn’t substitute for the other. In fact, having the translation empowers you; you can have a proper discussion about the transaction with your lawyer.

The decision you’re actually making

When you’re deciding whether to use artificial translation for your Greek property contract, you’re not deciding whether to save a few hundred euros on translation costs. You’re deciding whether to sign a legally binding agreement that will govern your ownership of a substantial asset based on information you cannot verify.

Greek property contracts are long, complex, and written in specialised legal language. Small errors in understanding key terms, encumbrances, or obligations can have significant financial and legal consequences. AI tools are useful for getting a rough sense of routine communications, but they’re not built for the accuracy and reliability that legal documents require.

For a binding Greek property contract, free artificial translation tools are too risky as a basis for signing.

If you’re buying property in Greece and need your contract and related documents translated, contact me for a professional translation. If you’ve already received an AI-generated translation and want an expert assessment of the problems in the output before you rely on it, I offer detailed reviews that walk you through the errors and explain what the Greek text actually says. Both services are available for a fee that reflects the specialist expertise required to handle Greek legal documents accurately.

Don’t sign based on a guess about what the contract says.

Get it translated properly.

Understand what you’re agreeing to.

And make your decision from a position of knowledge rather than hope.

 

A large Greek manufacturing company operates multiple facilities across the country. Head office develops workplace safety policies in Greek, including detailed procedures for end-of-shift protocols. One policy specifies when workers must perform a critical safety step: “Μετά το πέρας της βάρδιας”: after the end of the shift.

At a facility in a different part of the country employing significant numbers of foreign workers, local HR staff receive the new safety policy from head office. They use generative AI to translate it into English. AI renders “Μετά το πέρας της βάρδιας” as “at the end of the shift.” The English version is distributed to foreign workers and sent to the external contractor hired to deliver safety training in English. No one at the facility checks the translation against the Greek source. The compliance team at head office never sees the English version. Translation is treated as an administrative task, not a safety matter requiring technical review.

The foreign workers can’t read Greek. They rely entirely on the English translation to understand their safety obligations. The external trainer uses the translated document to deliver the training. The trainer doesn’t read Greek either. Workers are instructed to perform the safety step “at the end of the shift” while the machinery is still running, while hazards remain active, during the final moments of operational activity. The Greek instruction said to wait until after the shift ends. The English version says to act while the shift is ending. One preposition moved the compliance window into a hazard zone.

The safety risk

The timing of a safety instruction defines when a worker is protected. “After the end of the shift” means the safety step occurs when equipment has been powered down, when moving parts have stopped, when the work environment has transitioned from active to safe. The instruction assumes hazards have been neutralised before the worker acts.

“At the end of the shift” relocates that action to the closing moments of work when machinery is still operational, when the environment remains hazardous. The worker performs the same physical action, but in a different risk context. The mistranslation doesn’t change what the worker does. It changes when the worker is exposed.

This is how language determines the scope of safety obligations. Words specify the conditions under which a duty arises. Legal scholars examining statutory interpretation have documented how temporal markers (words like “after,” “during,” “before”) define when legal obligations apply and when they don’t[1]. When those markers are mistranslated, the obligation shifts to a different point in time, governed by different factual conditions.

In workplace safety, that shift can mean the difference between a controlled environment and an active hazard zone.

The legal problem

The company’s compliance documentation shows workers followed the English procedures. Inspectors review training records, incident logs, and safety audits; all based on the translated policy. Everything appears compliant.

But compliance with the English version is not compliance with the policy the company actually issued. The Greek source required one action. The English translation required another. Workers performed the action the translation instructed them to perform, not the action the company’s safety management system required.

If an injury occurs, the company cannot demonstrate that its workforce followed the procedures designed to mitigate the specific risk. The procedures workers followed were created by the translation error, not by the company’s safety assessment. The company has lost the ability to show that the control measure it designed was actually implemented.

The translated policy became a shadow document; an instruction that looks authoritative, that workers rely on, that trainers use, but that doesn’t match what the organisation requires under its own safety framework.

Why it happened

The output was fluent. The sentence structure was natural. “At the end of the shift” sounds plausible in English. No one checked the translation because they assumed AI handles this correctly. That assumption may appear reasonable. Translation tools have indeed improved. They remain problematic. They remain tools. And critically, most users don’t have the expertise to verify output in languages they don’t speak. So they can’t spot mistakes like this.

The error wasn’t visible to anyone in the chain: not to the HR department that distributed the policy, not to the contractor who delivered the training, not to the workers who implemented it. The only person who could have caught it would need to read both Greek and English, understand workplace safety terminology in both languages, and recognise that the temporal relationship between the safety step and the end of the shift had changed.

That’s not a linguistic skill. It’s a specialised professional competence that sits at the intersection of translation, legal interpretation, and occupational safety.

What this means for compliance

When legal and safety documents cross language boundaries, the translated text determines how obligations are understood and implemented. If the translation changes when a duty applies, it changes what compliance looks like in practice.

This isn’t unique to workplace safety. Contracts, regulatory filings, court judgments, and corporate policies all rely on precise language to define when parties must act, when rights vest, when duties terminate. Mistranslation of temporal language (or indeed any language that defines the conditions under which an obligation arises) creates a gap between what the document requires and what people believe it requires.

That gap invalidates the compliance chain. You can’t prove you followed a procedure if the procedure you followed was created by translation error.

Professional legal translators understand this. We know that translating “μετά” as “at” instead of “after” isn’t a minor linguistic choice. It’s a change in when the legal or safety obligation applies. We verify temporal markers, cross-check procedural language, and flag discrepancies that shift the scope of what’s required.

AI tools don’t do that. They produce fluent output that sounds correct. They don’t understand that one preposition determines whether a worker is safe or exposed. They don’t know when “close enough” isn’t close enough.

For companies relying on AI translation for legal or safety documents, the risk is that the translation becomes the policy. And that nobody notices until something goes wrong.

[1] see for example R. H. Fallon, “The Meaning of Legal ‘Meaning’ and Its Implications for Theories of Legal Interpretation,” University of Chicago Law Review 82:1235


Contact


If you would like further information about the specialised services we provide, or need a quote for a translation please feel free to contact us.

Name
Email
Message

Thank you for your message! We will get back to you as soon as possible.
There has been an eror in the form. Please validate the required fields.
© Copyright 2014 JurTrans